Choosing a roof is a big deal. It’s not just about what’s going over your head. It’s about what’s going to protect your family, affect your home’s energy bill, boost (or bust) curb appeal, and stick around for 50+ years.

If you’re torn between metal roofing and clay tiles, you’re not alone. These two premium contenders both offer impressive perks, but they’re also wildly different in terms of style, installation, and long-term performance.

Our residential construction experts break down metal roof vs. clay tile, section by section, so you can figure out which one is the right fit for your forever home.

How Much Does a New Metal Roof Increase Home Value?

Installing a metal roof can boost your home’s resale value by 60% to 85% of its cost, according to national remodeling reports. Buyers are willing to pay more for homes with roofs that last 40–70 years, cut energy bills, and resist wind, hail, and fire.

For example, if you invest $30,000 in a metal roof, you could see about $21,000 added to your home’s value — while enjoying lower maintenance and better curb appeal in the meantime.

Metal Roof vs. Clay Tile

First Impressions Matter: Aesthetics and Style

When people say, “Wow, that’s a beautiful home,” they’re usually looking at the roof (whether they realize it or not). And both clay tiles and metal roofing bring serious style, but in very different ways.

Clay Tiles: Timeless and Mediterranean-Chic

Clay roofs are the OGs of elegance. They’ve been around for thousands of years, and their classic red-orange tones instantly conjure visions of sun-drenched villas in Spain or Tuscany. They’re a favorite for:

• Mediterranean and Spanish Colonial homes
• Mission Revival architecture
• Upscale Southwestern builds

Think scalloped tiles, warm tones, and a look that ages beautifully. The tiles even develop a patina over time, kind of like fine wine.

Metal Roofing: Sleek, Modern, and Surprisingly Versatile

Metal roofs used to be the darlings of barns and industrial buildings. Not anymore. Today, they come in:

• Clean, modern profiles for minimalist homes
• Bold colors for statement-makers
• Stone-coated options that mimic clay tiles, slate, or shingles

You can go ultra-modern, rustic, or even traditional. If you want options, metal’s got ‘em.

Tip: Both clay and metal add value, but in different ways. Clay gives old-world charm, while metal offers a bold, modern edge (or an impressively convincing traditional look).

Built to Last: Durability and Weather Resistance

Now let’s talk about longevity. Because replacing a roof every 20 years? Hard pass.

Clay Tiles: Ancient, Durable, But Fragile

Clay tile roofs can last 50 to 100+ years if properly installed and maintained. They’re:

• Fire-resistant
• Rot- and insect-proof
• Naturally insulated

But, they’re fragile. Clay tiles can crack if walked on or hit by a falling branch. And if you live in a region that gets hail or freeze-thaw cycles, you’ll want to double-check their performance for your local climate.

Metal Roofing: Tough and Weather-Ready

Modern metal roofs are engineered to handle just about anything Mother Nature throws at them:

• High winds (up to 140 mph!)
• Hail (up to 2.5 inches in diameter)
• Snow loads
• Freeze-thaw cycles
• Wildfire-prone zones (Class A fire rating)

Depending on the metal you choose, steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc, you can expect a 40–70+ year lifespan, with some premium metals going well over a century.

Bottom Line: Clay is great for hot, dry climates. Metal? It’s your all-season warrior.

Weight and Installation: Is Your Home Ready?

Spoiler alert: Clay is heavy. Like, heavy.

Clay Tiles: Beautiful, But Bulky

Clay tiles can weigh 6–10x more than metal. That means:

• Older homes may need structural reinforcements
• Installation is more labor-intensive
• Costs can skyrocket if your roof needs strengthening

Metal Roofing: Lightweight and Flexible

Metal is lightweight, fast to install, and perfect for retrofits or older homes. No need for costly structural updates. Plus, some metal roofs can be installed right over existing shingles, reducing waste and labor time.

Tip: Always get a structural assessment before installing clay. Better safe (and supported) than sorry.

Energy Efficiency: Stay Cool (or Cozy)

Both roofing systems support energy efficiency, though they operate differently.

Clay Tiles: Nature’s Temperature Regulator

Clay tiles are naturally insulating. Their thermal mass absorbs heat during the day and releases it at night, creating a comfortable indoor environment year-round. They also allow airflow between the tiles and your roof deck — kind of like built-in passive ventilation.

Perfect for hot, sunny climates.

Metal Roofing: Reflective and Cool

Metal takes a different approach. Instead of absorbing heat, it reflects it, especially with reflective coatings known as “cool roofs.”

The result?

• Up to 25% lower cooling costs
• Less heat buildup in your attic
• Snow sheds quickly in winter, preventing ice dams

Both options are energy-efficient. Clay relies on natural insulation, while metal reflects and repels heat.

The Big Question: Cost and Long-Term Value

Let’s be honest. Neither of these roofing materials is cheap. But you get what you pay for.

Clay Tiles: Expensive Upfront, Worth It Long-Term

Expect to pay $13 to $25 per square foot, sometimes more, depending on tile style and region. That doesn’t include structural upgrades, which can add thousands to your bill.

BUT, spread over a 100-year lifespan? That cost starts to make sense.

Metal Roofing: Mid-Range with Fast ROI

Metal roofs usually fall in the $7 to $15 per square foot range. Installation is easier, and there’s often no need for structural upgrades. Plus:

• Lower energy bills
• Reduced maintenance
• Potential insurance discounts

Tip: Metal roofs often boost resale value by over $23,000 and reduce long-term ownership costs thanks to energy savings and fewer repairs.

Sustainability Showdown

If you’re building green, both metal and clay are solid eco-options, but for different reasons.

Clay Tiles: All-Natural and Long-Lived

• Made from abundant, natural clay
• Minimal chemical processing
• Biodegradable and recyclable
• It can last over a century with minimal replacements

Metal Roofing: The Recycling Hero

• Made with up to 95% recycled content
• 100% recyclable at the end of life
• Lightweight (less fuel for transport)
• Can be installed over old roofs, reducing landfill waste

Clay has a lower carbon footprint during its manufacturing process. Metal excels in terms of recyclability and reuse.

Metal Roof vs Clay Tile: So, Which Roof Is Right for You?

Honestly? It depends.

Here’s a quick cheat sheet:

Final Tip: Talk with an Expert Builder

Before making a decision, consult a roofing expert or a builder who’s installed both materials. They’ll help you understand:

• Structural readiness
• Local climate impacts
• Total project cost
• Regional availability

Remember, this is a roof you’ll be living with for decades. Choose what fits your home, your climate, your budget, and your style—and you’ll sleep better knowing you nailed it (literally).

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which lasts longer: clay tile or metal roofing?

Both materials offer impressive longevity. Clay tiles can last 50 to over 100 years, especially in dry climates. Metal roofs typically last 40 to 70 years, but high-end metals like copper or zinc can match or even exceed clay’s lifespan.

2. Are metal roofs noisy during rain or storms?

That’s a common myth! When properly installed with quality underlayment, metal roofs are no louder than any other roofing type. Most homeowners report no noticeable noise difference.

3. Can I walk on a clay tile roof or a metal roof?

Metal roofs can typically be walked on with care (ideally with a pro’s guidance). Clay tiles, however, are more fragile and can crack under pressure, so walking on them is best left to professionals.

4. Which roofing material is better for resale value?

Both offer excellent ROI. Clay tiles often appeal to buyers looking for luxury, heritage style, and long-term durability. Metal roofs boost resale thanks to their energy efficiency, low maintenance, and modern appeal. According to Remodeling Magazine, metal roofing can add $23,000+ to a home’s value.

5. Is one material better for solar panels?

Metal roofs are usually easier and more cost-effective for solar panel installation. Their durability and structure make them solar-friendly, and mounting systems often require fewer penetrations. Clay tiles can accommodate solar panels, too, but installation may be more complex and expensive.

6. What’s the biggest factor I should consider when choosing between the two?

Your climate, architectural style, and structural capacity are key. Clay tiles thrive in hot, dry areas and suit Mediterranean or Southwestern styles. Metal roofing adapts well to all climates and home designs, especially if you need something lighter and more versatile.

Custom Build Your Home with Trevino Luxury

Build your custom home with Treviño. From concept to completion, our team brings craftsmanship, precision, and elegance to every residential project. Whether you’re building from the ground up or transforming your existing space, Treviño delivers luxury that lasts. Check out our custom residential services and start creating your dream home today. Contact us today to learn more.